Potential Drawbacks and Challenges of Vertical Marketing Systems

man writing on whiteboard
Photo by Campaign Creators on Unsplash

Potential drawbacks and challenges of a VMS include:

  • Limited flexibility due to the rigid structure of some VMS types
  • Conflict management challenges arising from disagreements among supply chain members
  • Reduced return on investment (ROI)
  • Disputes between business partners

These challenges should be considered when implementing a VMS.

Limited Flexibility

Limited flexibility in a VMS can have significant implications on business performance, leading to reduced profit margins and diminished market share. Factors contributing to this constraint include being limited by suppliers or distributors, which restricts the ability to adapt to market changes.

Conflict Management

Disagreements among supply chain members necessitate robust conflict management to maintain a successful VMS. Tools and strategies for conflict resolution in a VMS include:

  • Establishing a minimum advertised price
  • Reducing distribution channels
  • Controlling the supply chain
  • Creating flexible yet solid channel partner agreements

Real-Life Examples of Successful Vertical Marketing Systems

Examining real-life examples of successful VMS, such as Zara’s agile supply chain and McDonald’s franchise model, vividly illustrates the concept of VMS. You can click here to see how a VMS was established in an online casino business.

Zara’s Agile Supply Chain

Zara’s VMS is a testament to the power of agility in supply chain management. Zara’s supply chain plays a vital role in its success by:

  • Emphasizing limited quantity production for exclusivity
  • Achieving growth through vertical integration
  • Pricing products based on market demands
  • Maintaining a highly responsive and adaptable system to keep up with fashion trends.

McDonald’s Franchise Model

McDonald’s franchise model is a prime example of a successful contractual VMS. It enlists different owners to operate each restaurant while maintaining a uniform menu and branding throughout all locations. The franchisees are obligated to adhere to strict guidelines for food preparation, cooking methods, and ingredient sourcing, and McDonald’s conducts routine audits to verify compliance and uphold quality standards.

Developing Your Own Vertical Marketing Strategy

When considering the implementation of a VMS in your business, identifying your business objectives, selecting an appropriate type of VMS, and building robust partnerships are pivotal.

Identifying Business Objectives

Before implementing a VMS, identifying your business objectives is of paramount importance. These objectives could include:

  • Increasing market share within a specific industry
  • Establishing the brand as a leader
  • Generating high-quality leads
  • Building customer loyalty
  • Expanding into new vertical markets

Selecting the Right Type of Vertical Marketing System

Relying on the company’s resources, partnerships, and market position, the selection of an appropriate type of VMS takes place. When selecting the appropriate VMS, it is important to:

  • Evaluate existing resources
  • Clearly define goals
  • Partner with the right entities
  • Thoroughly assess market conditions
  • Implement and monitor the system for performance.

Building Strong Partnerships

For a successful VMS, the establishment of strong partnerships is a crucial component. Establishing strong partnerships necessitates strategic alignment throughout the supply chain, collaborative assessment of partnership performance, and the establishment of a resilient team-selling model.


In summary, Vertical Marketing Systems offer a powerful strategy to streamline operations, enhance profitability, and strengthen a company’s competitive position. However, it’s crucial to be aware of potential drawbacks, such as limited flexibility and conflict management challenges. By understanding the types of VMS, identifying business objectives, and building strong partnerships, businesses can harness the power of vertical marketing to transform their operations and achieve their goals.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is an example of a vertical system?

Walmart is an example of an administered vertical marketing system, where the parties lack a formal contractual and corporate association with one another. Everyone’s size and strength impact their activities, allowing Walmart to operate such supervised systems.

What is a vertical approach in marketing?

A vertical approach in marketing targets specific industries or market segments to create tailored solutions and establish expertise within those niches. This strategy focuses on catering to the unique needs of a designated set of customers.

Is Walmart a vertical marketing system?

Yes, Walmart is considered a vertical marketing system because of its distribution channel structure without formal contractual relationships or corporate ownership among the parties involved.

What are the three types of VMS?

The three types of VMS are corporate, contractual, and administered. Each type has its own unique characteristics and strategies to consider.

How does a VMS enhance supply chain coordination?

A VMS enhances supply chain coordination by improving efficiency through the sharing of information and resources, leading to quicker lead times, fewer stockouts, and reduced costs.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here